1921
Volume 99, Issue 2
  • ISSN: 0002-9637
  • E-ISSN: 1476-1645

Abstract

Abstract.

Case–control studies are conducted to identify cholera transmission routes. Water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) exposures can facilitate cholera transmission (risk factors) or interrupt transmission (protective factors). To our knowledge, the association between WASH exposures and cholera from case–control studies has not been systematically analyzed. A systematic review was completed to close this gap, including describing the theory of risk and protection, developing inclusion criteria, searching and selecting studies, assessing quality of evidence, and summarizing associations between cholera and seven predicted WASH protective factors and eight predicted WASH risk factors using meta-analysis and sensitivity analysis. Overall, 47 articles describing 51 individual studies from 30 countries met the inclusion criteria. All eight predicted risk factors were associated with higher odds of cholera (odds ratio [OR] = 1.9–5.6), with heterogeneity ( ) of 0–92%. Of the predicted protective factors, five of seven were associated with lower odds of cholera (OR = 0.35–1.4), with heterogeneity of 57–91%; exceptions were insignificant associations for improved water source (OR = 1.1, heterogeneity 91%) and improved sanitation (OR = 1.4, heterogeneity 68%). Results were robust; 3/70 (5%) associations changed directionality or significance in sensitivity analysis. Meta-analysis results highlight that predicted risk factors are associated with cholera; however, predicted protective factors are not as consistently protective. This variable protection is attributed to 1) cholera transmission via multiple routes and 2) WASH intervention implementation quality variation. Water, sanitation, and hygiene interventions should address multiple transmission routes and be well implemented, according to international guidance, to ensure that field effectiveness matches theoretical efficacy. In addition, future case–control studies should detail WASH characteristics to contextualize results.

[open-access] This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0897
2018-08-02
2018-09-22
Loading full text...

Full text loading...

/deliver/fulltext/14761645/99/2/tpmd170897.html?itemId=/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0897&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

References

  1. Gaffga NH, Tauxe RV, Mintz ED, , 2007. Cholera: a new homeland in Africa? Am J Trop Med Hyg 77: 705713.
  2. WHO, 2017. Global Epidemics and Impact of Cholera. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. Available at: http://www.who.int/topics/cholera/impact/en/. Accessed April 24, 2017.
  3. Ali M, Lopez AL, You YA, Kim YE, Sah B, Maskery B, Clemens J, , 2012. The global burden of cholera. Bull World Health Organ 90: 209218A.
  4. Nygren BL, Blackstock AJ, Mintz ED, , 2014. Cholera at the crossroads: the association between endemic cholera and national access to improved water sources and sanitation. Am J Trop Med Hyg 91: 10231028.
  5. Harris JB, LaRocque RC, Qadri F, Ryan ET, Calderwood SB, , 2012. Cholera. Lancet 379: 24662476.
  6. Yates T, Allen JV, Jospeh ML, Gallandat K, Lantagne DS, . Water, sanitation, and hygiene interventions in disease outbreak response in low and middle-income countries. Syst Rev (In press).
  7. Water 1st International, 2017. F Diagram—Water1st International. Available at: https://water1st.org/problem/f-diagram/. Accessed May 3, 2017.
  8. Department for International Development, 2013. An Evidence Review of Research on Health Interventions in Humanitarian Crises. Research for Development Output—GOV.UK. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/dfid-research-outputs/an-evidence-review-of-research-on-health-interventions-in-humanitarian-crises-final-report-november-2013. Accessed April 24, 2017.
  9. Ramesh A, Blanchet K, Ensink JHJ, Roberts B, , 2015. Evidence on the effectiveness of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions on health outcomes in humanitarian crises: a systematic review. PLoS One 10: e0124688.
  10. Brown J, Cavill S, Cumming O, Jeandron A, , 2012. Water, sanitation, and hygiene in emergencies: summary review and recommendations for further research. Waterlines 31: 1129.
  11. Taylor DL, Kahawita TM, Cairncross S, Ensink JHJ, , 2015. The impact of water, sanitation and hygiene interventions to control cholera: a systematic review. PLoS One 10: e0135676.
  12. Himmelfarb Health Sciences Library, 2011. Study Design 101—Case Control. Available at: https://himmelfarb.gwu.edu/tutorials/studydesign101/casecontrols.html. Accessed October 10, 2017.
  13. Transparent Reporting of Systematic Reviews and Meta analyses, 2015. PRISMA. Available at: http://www.prisma-statement.org/. Accessed April 6, 2017.
  14. Higgins J, Green S, , eds., 2011. Defining the review question and developing inclusion criteria. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [Updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration. Available at: http://handbook.cochrane.org/chapter_5/5_defining_the_review_question_and_developing_criteria_for.htm. Accessed April 6, 2017.
  15. Fung IC-H, Fitter DL, Borse RH, Meltzer MI, Tappero JW, , 2013. Modeling the effect of water, sanitation, and hygiene and oral cholera vaccine implementation in Haiti. Am J Trop Med Hyg 89: 633640.
  16. Waddington H, Snilstveit B, Hombrados JG, Vojtkova M, Anderson J, White H, , 2014. Farmer Field Schools for Improving Farming Practices and Farmer Outcomes in Low- and Middle-Income Countries. Oslo, Norway: The Campbell Collaboration.
  17. WHO, 2018. Prevention and Control of Cholera Outbreaks: WHO Policy and Recommendations. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. Available at: http://www.who.int/cholera/technical/prevention/control/en/index1.html. Accessed April 6, 2017.
  18. Effective Public Health Practice Project. EPHPP Quality Assessment Tool for Quantitative Studies. Available at: http://www.ephpp.ca/tools.html. Accessed May 3, 2017.
  19. GSDRC, 2013. Relative Effectiveness of Conditional and Unconditional Cash Transfers for Schooling Outcomes in Developing Countries, A Systematic Review. Available at: http://www.gsdrc.org/document-library/relative-effectiveness-of-conditional-and-unconditional-cash-transfers-for-schooling-outcomes-in-developing-countries-a-systematic-review/. Accessed May 3, 2017.
  20. WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme, 2016. WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme: Wat/San Ladder. Available at: http://www.wssinfo.org/definitions-methods/watsan-ladder/. Accessed March 26, 2016.
  21. Cairncross S, Hunt C, Boisson S, Bostoen K, Curtis V, Fung IC, Schmidt W-P, , 2010. Water, sanitation and hygiene for the prevention of diarrhoea. Int J Epidemiol 39 (Suppl 1): i193i205.
  22. Fewtrell L, Kaufmann RB, Kay D, Enanoria W, Haller L, Colford JM, Jr., 2005. Water, sanitation, and hygiene interventions to reduce diarrhoea in less developed countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Infect Dis 5: 4252.
  23. Beatty ME, Jack T, Sivapalasingam S, Yao SS, Paul I, Bibb B, Greene KD, Kubota K, Mintz ED, Brooks JT, , 2004. An outbreak of Vibrio cholerae O1 infections on Ebeye island, Republic of the Marshall Islands, associated with use of an adequately chlorinated water source. Clin Infect Dis 38: 19.
  24. Kone-Coulibaly A, Tshimanga M, Shambira G, Gombe NT, Chadambuka A, Chonzi P, Mungofa S, , 2010. Risk factors associated with cholera in Harare city, Zimbabwe, 2008. East Afr J Public Health 7: 311317.
  25. Bhunia R, Ghosh S, , 2011. Waterborne cholera outbreak following Cyclone Aila in Sundarban area of West Bengal, India, 2009. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 105: 214219.
  26. Rodrigues A, Sandström A, T, Steinsland H, Jensen H, Aaby P, , 2000. Protection from cholera by adding lime juice to food—results from community and laboratory studies in Guinea-Bissau, West Africa. Trop Med Int Health 5: 418422.
  27. Louis MES, Porter JD, Helal A, Drame K, Hargrett-Bean N, Wells JG, Tauxe RV, , 1990. Epidemic cholera in West Africa: the role of food handling and high-risk foods. Am J Epidemiol 131: 719728.
  28. O’Connor KA, 2011. Risk factors early in the 2010 cholera epidemic, Haiti. Emerg Infect Dis 17: 21362138.
  29. Opare J, Ohuabunwo C, Afari E, Wurapa F, Sackey S, Der J, Afakye K, Odei E, , 2012. Outbreak of cholera in the east Akim municipality of Ghana following unhygienic practices by small-scale gold miners, November 2010. Ghana Med J 46: 116123.
  30. Acosta CJ, 2001. Cholera outbreak in southern Tanzania: risk factors and patterns of transmission. Emerg Infect Dis 7 (Suppl): 583587.
  31. Cárdenas V, Saad C, Varona M, Linero M, , 1993. Waterborne cholera in Riohacha, Colombia, 1992. Bull Pan Am Health Organ 27: 313330.
  32. Dunkle SE, 2011. Epidemic cholera in a crowded urban environment, Port-au-Prince, Haiti. Emerg Infect Dis 17: 21432146.
  33. Fredrick T, Ponnaiah M, Murhekar MV, Jayaraman Y, David JK, Vadivoo S, Joshua V, , 2015. Cholera outbreak linked with lack of safe water supply following a tropical cyclone in Pondicherry, India, 2012. J Health Popul Nutr 33: 3138.
  34. Reller ME, Mong YJM, Hoekstra RM, Quick RE, , 2001. Cholera prevention wiith traditional and novel water treatment methods: an outbreak investigation in Fort-Dauphin, Madagascar. Am J Public Health 91: 16081610.
  35. Rodrigues A, Brun H, Sandstrom A, , 1997. Risk factors for cholera infection in the initial phase of an epidemic in Guinea-Bissau: protection by lime juice. Am J Trop Med Hyg 57: 601604.
  36. Shapiro RL, Otieno MR, Adcock PM, Phillips-Howard PA, Hawley WA, Kumar L, Waiyaki P, Nahlen BL, Slutsker L, , 1999. Transmission of epidemic Vibrio cholerae O1 in rural western Kenya associated with drinking water from lake victoria: an environmental reservoir for cholera? Am J Trop Med Hyg 60: 271276.
  37. Von Seidlein L, 2008. Is HIV infection associated with an increased risk for Cholera? Findings from a case–control study in Mozambique. Trop Med Int Health 13: 683688.
  38. De Guzman A, de los Reyes VC, Sucaldito MN, Tayag E, , 2015. Availability of safe drinking-water: the answer to cholera outbreak? Nabua, Camarines Sur, Philippines, 2012. Western Pac Surveill Response J 6: 1216.
  39. Hutin Y, Luby S, Paquet C, , 2003. A large cholera outbreak in Kano city, Nigeria: the importance of hand washing with soap and the danger of street-vended water. J Water Health 1: 4552.
  40. Izadi S, Tabatabaei S-M, Miradi M-R, Sheikhzadeh K, , 2005. Routes of transmission of cholera in the border areas of Zahedan district, Sistan and Baluchestan Province, summer 2003. J Med Sci 5: 233238.
  41. Koo D, 1996. Epidemic cholera in Guatemala, 1993: transmission of a newly introduced epidemic strain by street vendors. Epidemiol Infect 116: 121126.
  42. Mahamud AS, 2011. Epidemic cholera in Kakuma refugee camp, Kenya, 2009: the importance of sanitation and soap. J Infect Dev Ctries 6: 234241.
  43. Nsagha DS, Atashili J, Fon PN, Tanue EA, Ayima CW, Kibu OD, , 2015. Assessing the risk factors of cholera epidemic in the Buea health district of Cameroon. BMC Public Health 15: 1128.
  44. Nguyen VD, 2014. Cholera epidemic associated with consumption of unsafe drinking water and street-vended water—eastern Freetown, Sierra Leone, 2012. Am J Trop Med Hyg 90: 518523.
  45. Rosewell A, 2012. Cholera risk factors, Papua New Guinea, 2010. BMC Infect Dis 12: 287.
  46. Kirk MD, Kiedrzynski T, Johnson E, Elymore A, Wainiqolo I, , 2005. Risk factors for cholera in Pohnpei during an outbreak in 2000: lessons for Pacific countries and territories. Pac Health Dialog 12: 1722.
  47. Siddiqui FJ, 2006. Consecutive outbreaks of Vibrio cholerae O139 and V. cholerae O1 cholera in a fishing village near Karachi, Pakistan. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 100: 476482.
  48. Moren A, Stefanaggi S, Antona D, Bitar D, Etchegorry MG, Tchatchioka M, Lungu G, , 1991. Practical field epidemiology to investigate a cholera outbreak in a Mozambican refugee camp in Malawi, 1988. J Trop Med Hyg 94: 17.
  49. Swerdlow DL, Malenga G, Begkoyian G, Nyangulu D, Toole M, Waldman RJ, Puhr DN, Tauxe RV, , 1997. Epidemic cholera among refugees in Malawi, Africa: treatment and transmission. Epidemiol Infect 118: 207214.
  50. Uthappa CK, Allam RR, Nalini C, Gunti D, Udaragudi PR, Tadi GP, Murhekar MV, , 2015. An outbreak of cholera in Medipally village, Andhra Pradesh, India, 2013. J Health Popul Nutr 33: 7.
  51. Sasaki S, Suzuki H, Igarashi K, Tambatamba B, Mulenga P, , 2008. Spatial analysis of risk factor of cholera outbreak for 2003–2004 in a Peri-urban area of Lusaka, Zambia. Am J Trop Med Hyg 79: 414421.
  52. Birmingham ME, Lee LA, Ndayimirije N, Nkurikiye S, Hersh BS, Wells JG, Deming MS, , 1997. Epidemic cholera in Burundi: patterns of transmission in the Great Rift valley lake region. Lancet 349: 981985.
  53. Arnold BF, Colford JM, Jr., 2007. Treating water with chlorine at the point-of-use to improve water quality and reduce child diarrhea in developing countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Trop Med Hyg 76: 354364.
  54. Clasen T, Schmidt W-P, Rabie T, Roberts I, Cairncross S, , 2007. Interventions to improve water quality for preventing diarrhoea: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ 334: 782.
  55. Lantagne DS, Quick R, Mintz ED, , 2006. Household water treatment and safe storage options in developing countries. Navig 17.
  56. Hoge CW, Bodhidatta L, Echeverria P, Deesuwan M, Kitporka P, , 1996. Epidemiologic study of Vibrio cholerae O1 and O139 in Thailand: at the advancing edge of the eighth pandemic. Am J Epidemiol 143: 263268.
  57. Mridha P, Biswas AK, Ramakrishnan R, Murhekar MV, , 2011. The 2010 outbreak of cholera among workers of a jute mill in Kolkata, West Bengal, India. J Health Popul Nutr 29: 913.
  58. Mugoya I, 2008. Rapid spread of Vibrio cholerae O1 throughout Kenya, 2005. Am J Trop Med Hyg 78: 527533.
  59. Quick RE, 1995. Epidemic cholera in rural El Salvador: risk factors in a region covered by a cholera prevention campaign. Epidemiol Infect 114: 249255.
  60. Weber JT, 1994. Epidemic cholera in Ecuador: multidrug-resistance and transmission by water and seafood. Epidemiol Infect 112: 111.
  61. Cummings MJ, Wamala JF, Eyura M, Malimbo M, Omeke ME, Mayer D, Lukwago L, , 2012. A cholera outbreak among semi-nomadic pastoralists in northeastern Uganda: epidemiology and interventions. Epidemiol Infect 140: 13761385.
  62. Mujica OJ, Quick RE, Palacios AM, Beingolea L, Vargas R, Moreno D, Barrett TJ, Bean NH, Seminario L, Tauxe RV, , 1994. Epidemic cholera in the Amazon: the role of produce in disease risk and prevention. J Infect Dis 169: 13811384.
  63. Swerdlow DL, 1992. Waterborne transmission of epidemic cholera in Trujillo, Peru: lessons for a continent at risk. Lancet 340: 2833.
  64. DuBois AE, Sinkala M, Kalluri P, Makasa-Chikoya M, Quick RE, , 2006. Epidemic cholera in urban Zambia: hand soap and dried fish as protective factors. Epidemiol Infect 134: 12261230.
  65. Ries AA, 1992. Cholera in Piura, Peru: a modern urban epidemic. J Infect Dis 166: 14291433.
  66. Grandesso F, 2014. Risk factors for cholera transmission in Haiti during inter-peak periods: insights to improve current control strategies from two case-control studies. Epidemiol Infect 142: 16251635.
  67. Ujjiga TTA, 2015. Risk factors for sustained cholera transmission, Juba county, South Sudan, 2014. Emerg Infect Dis 21: 18491852.
  68. Mintz ED, Reiff FM, Tauxe RV, , 1995. Safe water treatment and storage in the home: a practical new strategy to prevent waterborne disease. JAMA 273: 948953.
  69. Shultz A, Omollo JO, Burke H, Qassim M, Ochieng JB, Weinberg M, Feikin DR, Breiman RF, , 2009. Cholera outbreak in Kenyan refugee camp: risk factors for illness and importance of sanitation. Am J Trop Med Hyg 80: 640645.
  70. WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme, 2016. WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme: Wat/San Categories. Available at: http://www.wssinfo.org/definitions-methods/watsan-categories/. Accessed March 26, 2016.
  71. Hatch DL, Waldman RJ, Lungu GW, Piri C, , 1994. Epidemic cholera during refugee resettlement in Malawi. Int J Epidemiol 23: 12921299.
  72. Fatiregun AA, Ajayi IO, Isere EE, , 2013. Cholera outbreak in a southwest community of Nigeria: investigation of risk factors and evaluation of a district surveillance system. West Afr J Med 32: 173179.
  73. Zwane AP, Kremer M, , 2007. What works in fighting diarrheal diseases in developing countries? A critical review. World Bank Res Obs 22: 124.
  74. Luby SP, Agboatwalla M, Painter J, Altaf A, Billhimer WL, Hoekstra RM, , 2004. Effect of intensive handwashing promotion on childhood diarrhea in high-risk communities in Pakistan: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 291: 25472554.
  75. Izadi S, Shakeri H, Roham P, Sheikhzadeh K, , 2006. Cholera outbreak in southeast of Iran: routes of transmission in the situation of good primary health care services and poor individual hygienic practices. Jpn J Infect Dis 59: 174178.
  76. Enger KS, Nelson KL, Rose JB, Eisenberg JNS, , 2013. The Joint effects of efficacy and compliance: a study of household water treatment effectiveness against childhood diarrhea. Water Res 47: 11811190.
  77. Waddington H, Snilstveit B, , 2009. Effectiveness and sustainability of water, sanitation, and hygiene interventions in combating diarrhoea. J Dev Effect 1: 295335.
  78. Wolf J, 2014. Assessing the impact of drinking water and sanitation on diarrhoeal disease in low- and middle-income settings: systematic review and meta-regression. Trop Med Int Health 19: 928942.
  79. Eisenberg JNS, Scott JC, Porco T, , 2007. Integrating disease control strategies: balancing water sanitation and hygiene interventions to reduce diarrheal disease burden. Am J Public Health 97: 846852.
  80. Kvarnström E, McConville J, Bracken P, Johansson M, Fogde M, , 2011. The sanitation ladder—a need for a revamp? J Water Sanit Hyg Dev 1: 312.
  81. Exley JLR, Liseka B, Cumming O, Ensink JHJ, , 2015. The sanitation ladder, what constitutes an improved form of sanitation? Environ Sci Technol 49: 10861094.
  82. Naik KS, Stenstrom MK, , 2012. Evidence of the influence of wastewater treatment on improved public health. Water Sci Technol 66: 644652.
  83. Sozzi E, Fabre K, Fesselet J-F, Ebdon JE, Taylor H, , 2015. Minimizing the risk of disease transmission in emergency settings: novel in situ physico-chemical disinfection of pathogen-laden hospital wastewaters. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 9: e0003776.
  84. United Nations, 2015. Goal 6. Sustainable Development Knowledge Platform. Available at: https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/sdg6. Accessed May 3, 2017.
  85. WHO, 2012. Rapid Assessment of Drinking-Water Quality: A Handbook for Implementation. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. Available at: http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/publications/rapid_assessment/en/. Accessed October 30, 2017.
  86. Bhunia R, Ramakrishnan R, Hutin Y, Gupte MD, , 2009. Cholera outbreak secondary to contaminated pipe water in an urban area, West Bengal, India, 2006. Indian J Gastroenterol 28: 6264.
  87. Loevinsohn M, Mehta L, Cuming K, Nicol A, Cumming O, Ensink JHJ, , 2015. The cost of a knowledge silo: a systematic re-review of water, sanitation and hygiene interventions. Health Policy Plan 30: 660674.
http://instance.metastore.ingenta.com/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0897
Loading
/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0897
Loading

Data & Media loading...

Supplementary Data

Supplemental Tables

  • Received : 17 Nov 2017
  • Accepted : 15 May 2018

Most Cited This Month

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error