|
|
||||||||
| ABSTRACT |
|
|
|---|
| BACKGROUND |
|
|
|---|
In March 1993, the Malawi Ministry of Health and Population was the first sub-Saharan country to adopt sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) as national first-line treatment of uncomplicated malaria. Since 1997, increasing Plasmodium falciparum resistance to SP has been documented, with efficacy studies demonstrating 14-day parasitologic failure rates as high as 35%.3 Since SP and TS provide their antimicrobial action through inhibition of the same enzymes in the folic acid biosynthetic pathway (pyrimethamine and trimethoprim inhibit dihydrofolate reductase, whereas sulfadoxine and sulfamethoxazole inhibit dihydropteroate synthetase), cross-resistance could develop, and a decrease in the antimalarial efficacy of TS may occur in parallel with SP resistance development. At least two studies have demonstrated that cross-resistance between the two drugs may occur.4,5
The Malawi Ministry of Health and Population plans to implement IMCI guidelines in all outpatient health facilities. The adapted Malawian guidelines recommend TS as the first-line treatment option for dual classifications of pneumonia and malaria; SP plus erythromycin (SP plus E) is recommended as second-line treatment. Thus, it is essential that policy makers know the antimalarial efficacy of a five-day course of TS. We conducted a study to measure the efficacy of TS compared with SP plus E for treatment of P. falciparum malaria among children with dual IMCI classifications of malaria and pneumonia. We did not design this study to measure the efficacy of TS or E in treating IMCI-classified pneumonia.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|
|
|---|
Study design. We conducted a non-blinded, randomized, controlled trial based on a 14-day World Health Organization in vivo protocol for assessing the efficacy of antimalarial drugs in areas of intense transmission.7
Patients. Inclusion criteria for the study were 1) child between the ages of six months and five years; 2) presentation to the outpatient clinic at the Chilomoni health facility with an IMCI classification of malaria (history of or current fever) and pneumonia (cough or difficult breathing and elevated respiratory rate for age) without signs of severe disease; 3) thick and thin blood films with a non-mixed P. falciparum infection with at least 2,000 asexual parasites/µL; and 4) informed consent from a guardian with agreement to admit the child to the inpatient facility for five days of observation where study drugs were administered.
Children with signs or symptoms of severe illness, with a hemoglobin level < 5 g/dL, or those with a sulfa or quinine allergy were excluded from the study. Prior antimicrobial drug use was not a reason for exclusion.
The study was reviewed and approved by the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Institutional Review Board and the Malawi National Health Sciences Research Committee.
Enrollment and treatment.
Enrolled children provided a thorough history and underwent a physical examination by study clinicians trained in IMCI. Temperatures were taken using an aural thermometer. Children who were found to be febrile, with a temperature
38.0°C, or who had a history of fever during this illness, and who had an IMCI classification of pneumonia were sent to the laboratory for a thick blood film and a hemoglobin measurement using HemoCue® cuvettes (HemoCue, Ångelholm, Sweden). Those children who were parasitemic, with a screening parasite density of at least 2,000 asexual parasites/µL of blood, were randomized to receive either a five-day course of TS (80 mg of trimethoprim and 400 mg of sulfamethoxazole per tablet [1 tablet for children weighing 1019 kg; half a tablet for children weighing < 10 kg]) or SP (500 mg of sulfadoxine and 25 mg of pyrimethamine per tablet [1.25 mg of pyrimethamine/kg of body weight]) plus a five-day course of erythromycin (125 mg four times a day if they weighed < 10 kg; 250 mg four times a day if they weighed
10 kg) to treat the respiratory infection.
Enrolled children were given the study medication orally and admitted to the study ward (considered day 0) where they were observed throughout the period that study medications were administered (days 04). The study ward was staffed by study nurses who remained on the ward at all times and who assessed every childs vital signs and health status every six hours. A senior clinician or medical officer was available to the nursing staff at all times, and lead daily study ward rounds.
Children were observed for 30 minutes after the study drug was administered. Those who vomited the study drug(s) within 30 minutes of administration were provided a second full dose of the medication(s). Those with hemoglobin levels
5.0 g/dL and
8 g/dL received a 30-day course of daily iron without folate, beginning on day 0, according to Malawi guidelines for treatment of malariaassociated anemia. Children > 2 years old who had not received albendazole within the past six months were given this drug, in accordance with Ministry of Health guidelines. All children received paracetamol every eight hours for fever.
Malaria microscopy. After randomization, a second finger-prick was done for malaria thick and thin films. The second film, and all follow-up films, were dried and stained with Giemsa in the clinic. Parasite density was determined by counting the number of asexual parasites against 200 leukocytes, and by assuming a white blood cell count of 8,000/µL of blood. Slides were considered negative if no parasites were found after examining 100 high-powered fields.
Each blood smear was examined by two study technicians, who independently recorded parasite densities. Parasite density readings for each slide were compared and those that differed by greater than three-fold were read by a third technician. The geometric mean of the two nearest estimates of parasite density was used in the analysis.
Study drug. Brand name TS and SP were obtained from reputable multinational pharmaceutical companies. Samples from single pharmaceutical lots of TS and SP were tested to evaluate quality of the study drugs. The levels of active ingredients for both TS and SP were tested using high-performance liquid chromatography at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (Atlanta, GA). Both TS and SP were found to have acceptable levels of active ingredients.
Follow-up. Children were evaluated daily on the study ward until the five-day course of antimicrobials was completed. After discharge, they were followed on days 7 and 14, or earlier if they returned to the health facility due to illness. Each day on the study ward and at every follow-up visit, the child was checked for, or parents were asked about, eating patterns, vomiting, convulsions, and the use of other medications. Each child was examined, and temperature was measured. A blood sample was taken for a thick malaria smear on days 14, 7, 14, or any sick visit, and hemoglobin was measured on day 14. The presence or absence of gametocytemia was recorded. For all day 7 blood smears, gametocyte density was determined. Children classified as treatment failures were treated with oral quinine.
Outcome measures.
Clinical and parasitologic outcomes were defined using a modified version of the World Health Organization classification system for clinical and parasitologic response. Outcomes were classified as an early treatment failure (ETF), late clinical failure (LCF), late parasitologic failure (LPF), or adequate clinical and parasitologic response (ACPR).8 We included children with reported fever during the 24 hours prior to enrollment, regardless of their temperature on presentation. At follow-up visits, a reported fever during the previous 24 hours or an aural temperature
38.0°C were considered true fever when determining clinical response (Table 1
).
|
38.0 during the follow-up period. Children who had persistent fever at day 14 were censored in the analysis.
To compare results presented in this report with results from prior efficacy studies, we also present outcome data using the World Health Organization definitions for adequate clinical response (ACR) and for parasitologic outcome that were standard prior to the year 2003.7 An ACR can be calculated by combining the percentage of children with ACPR and LPF. In reporting parasitologic response, we combined late RI with sensitive responses because late RI (days 1528) could not be assessed in this 14-day trial (Table 2
).
|
| RESULTS |
|
|
|---|
2,000 parasites/µL of blood, fever within the previous 24 hours, and no exclusion criteria. Parents of 205 children consented to enrollment in the study.
Of the 205 enrolled children, 104 children were randomized to the TS arm and 101 children were randomized to the SP plus E arm. The clinical and parasitologic characteristics of the children and their illnesses are summarized in Table 3
, and did not differ by treatment arm. Two children (one randomized to each of the treatment arms) were withdrawn from the study after enrollment because their mothers were needed at home. No children were lost to follow-up.
|
Clinical response.
A total of 202 (98.5%) of enrolled children had their clinical outcome evaluated. Among those 102 children who received TS, 89, (87.2%) achieved ACPR. Among the 100 children who received SP plus E, 80 (80.0%) were classified as ACPR. There was no significant difference in clinical and parasitologic response between the two treatment arms (Table 4
and Figure 1
). However, the percentage of children who achieved ACR was higher in the TS arm (98 of 102 [96.1%] than in the SP plus E arm (88 of 100 [88.0%]; P = 0.03).
|
|
38.0°C. Of them, only one child in the TS arm and two children in the SP plus E arm had a temperature
38.0°C on day 14 (P = 0.97). Among children with fever at presentation, the median time to fever resolution was 30 hours in the TS arm and 36 hours in the SP plus E arm. Children who received TS resolved fever sooner than those who received SP plus E (P = 0.03) (Figure 2
|
|
Hematologic response.
Hemotologic response was measured in 199 (97.1%) children. Prevalence of anemia was similar at day 0. A total of 42.2% of the children in the TS arm and 49.0% of those in the SP plus E arm had an initial hemoblobin level
8 (P = 0.33). Children in both study arms had an increase from day 0 to day 14 in mean hemoglobin levels. The mean (± SD) hemoglobin increase between days 0 and 14 was 1.0 g/dL (± 1.7) in the TS arm and 1.1 g/dL (± 1.5) in the SP plus E arm (P = 0.76). On day 14, 10.8% of children in the TS arm and 13.3% of those in the SP plus E arm had a hemoglobin level
8 g/dL (P = 0.46).
Factors influencing hematologic outcome.
Children who achieved ACPR had a greater increase in mean hemoglobin level between days 0 and 14 (1.14 g/dL) when compared with children who did not achieve ACPR (0.39 g/dL) (P = 0.004). Children with initial hemoglobin level
5.0 g/dL and
8.0 g/dL (46% of enrollees), all of whom received iron, had a greater mean increase in the hemoglobin level than those with an initial hemoglobin level > 8.0 g/dL (1.99 g/dL versus 0.24 g/dL, respectively) (P < 0.0001). A total of 16 children (9%), 8 in each study arm, received albendazole. There was no evidence that childs age, sex, nutritional status, albendazole administration, or initial parasite density was associated with hematologic outcome. Achieving ACPR was not significantly associated with a decreased prevalence of anemia, and having persistent asymptomatic parasitemia (LPF) was not associated with increased risk of anemia at day 14.
Gametocyte response.
Gametocyte prevalence on day 7 was high and similar in both study arms. A total of 55% of the children in the TS arm and 64% of the children in the SP plus E arm had gametocytes detectable on day 7. Median (mean) gametocyte density was 320 (723) gametocytes/µL of blood in the TS arm with a range of 409,600 gametocytes/µL, and 180 (676) gametocytes/µL in the SP plus E arm with a range of 406,600 gametocytes/µL, (P = 0.23). Risk factors for gametocytemia on day 7 included an initial hemoglobin level
5 g/dL and
8 g/dL when compared with a hemoglobin level > 8 g/dL (RR = 1.26, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.011.58) and fever duration less than three days prior to presentation when compared with fever of longer duration (RR = 1.30, 95% CI = 1.031.64).
Adverse drug effects. One child vomited SP within 30 minutes after administration. A second dose was successfully administered. No child vomited TS. No child had a rash or other notable adverse reaction. Sixteen (15.5%) children administered TS and 11 (11%) children administered SP plus E vomited during their illness (P = 0.34).
| DISCUSSION |
|
|
|---|
Importantly, we still do not know the effectiveness of TS, that is, how well it works when administered at home, outside of the study setting. The effectiveness will depend largely on the caregivers adherence to a five-day treatment course. In a study of TS antimalarial effectiveness in The Gambia, only 67% of the patients adhered to the TS five-day treatment course.2 In Uganda, where the clinical efficacy of SP for P. falciparum infection is as high as 90%, clinical effectiveness among children with malaria treated with TS varied from 59% to 90%, depending on the study site.9,10 The investigators speculate one reason for the poor treatment response may have been non-adherence to the five-day drug treatment regimen. There are no recent data on the antimalarial efficacy of a shortened course of TS.
A series of SP efficacy studies conducted throughout Malawi since 1993 show a steady decrease in clinical and parasitologic efficacy. However, in most of these studies, ACR remains greater than 80% (Table 6
). The level of SP plus E efficacy found in our study is on the higher end of findings from other SP efficacy studies. It should be noted that erythromycin does have mild antimalarial properties, which may have increased the efficacy of SP in our study.
|
Several studies have documented high gametocytemia prevalence associated with SP treatment when compared with other antimalarial drugs, with peak gametocyte prevalence occurring around day 7 following treatment.1216 To our knowledge, this is the first study to demonstrate a similar increase in gametocytemia after treatment with TS. Gametocytes, the sexual form of the malaria parasite, are infective to the mosquito and responsible for malaria transmission. A study of gametocyte infectivity following treatment with SP and other antimalarials has documented persistent transmissibility following antimalarial therapy.17 It remains unknown whether transmission of these gametocytes results in transmission of mutant resistant genotypes. Furthermore, it is unclear if the transmission of mutant resistant genotypes would significantly contribute to drug resistance in an area where transmission is already high. More research will be needed to explore these questions.
In conclusion, we found that at Chilomoni Health Center, both TS and SP plus E are efficacious, well-tolerated treatment options for uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria among children with IMCI classifications of malaria and pneumonia. Children with malnutrition are especially prone to fail therapy, and in times of famine, health workers will need to be diligent in reminding caretakers to return for follow-up to confirm the child has successfully responded to treatment or to change the child to a second-line drug therapy. If Ministries of Health continue to choose TS as a treatment choice for IMCI dual classifications of malaria and pneumonia, it will be important to measure adherence to the five-day TS treatment course.
Received September 10, 2004. Accepted for publication April 13, 2005.
Acknowledgments: We thank the study staff and the Chilomoni Health Center staff for their hard work and dedication to completing this study. We also thank the study participants, parents, and community of Chilomoni.
Financial support: This study was supported by the African Integrated Malaria Initiative (7921-3079) of the United States Agency for International Development.
* Address correspondence to Mary J. Hamel, Malaria Branch, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/Kenya Medical Research Institute Research Station, Unit 64112, APO, AE, 09831. E-mail: mhamel{at}ke.cdc.gov ![]()
Authors addresses: Mary J. Hamel, Malaria Branch, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/Kenya Medical Research Institute Research Station, APO AE 09831, Telephone: 254-57-20-22902, Fax: 254-57-20-22981, E-mail: mhamel{at}ke.cdc.gov. Timothy Holtz, National Center for HIV, STD, and TB Prevention, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1600 Clifton Road, Atlanta, GA 30333, Telephone: 404-639-3311, Fax: 770-488-7761, E-mail: tholtz{at}cdc.gov. Christopher Mkandala and Nyokase Kaimila, Blantyre District Health Office, Private Bag 66, Blantyre, Malawi, Telephone and Fax: 265-1-676-071, E-mails: cmkandala{at}yahoo.com and nkaimila{at}cdcmalaria.org. Nyson Chizani, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention-Malawi Malaria Program, Private Bag 240, Blantyre, Malawi, Telephone: 265-1-676-071, Fax: 265-1-677-371, E-mail: nchisani{at}cdcmalaria.org. Peter Bloland, Malaria Branch, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1600 Clifton Road, Atlanta, GA 30333, Telephone: 770-488-7755, Fax: 770-488-7761, E-mail: pbloland{at}cdc.gov. James Kublin, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, 1100 Fairview Avenue, PO Box 19024, Seattle, WA 98109, Telephone: 206-667-1970, Fax: 206-667-4411, E-mail: jkublin{at}fhcrc.org. Peter Kazembe, Malawi Ministry of Health, Lilongwe, Malawi, Telephone: 265-8-822-447, E-mail: pnkazembe{at}malawi.net. Richard Steketee, Program for Appropriate Technology in Health, 1455 NW Leary Way, Seattle, WA 98107, Telephone: 206-285-3500, Fax: 206-285-6619, E-mail: ris1{at}cdc.gov.
Reprint requests: Mary J. Hamel, Malaria Branch, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/Kenya Medical Research Institute Research Station, Unit 64112, APO, AE, 09831.
| REFERENCES |
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Nzila The past, present and future of antifolates in the treatment of Plasmodium falciparum infection J. Antimicrob. Chemother., June 1, 2006; 57(6): 1043 - 1054. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |