|
|
||||||||
| ABSTRACT |
|
|
|---|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
|
|---|
The study of indigenous populations is useful in understanding the relationship between the source of infection with T. gondii and its occurrence, especially since these communities usually have long-established customs and habits. Furthermore, the study of their lifestyles may facilitate the identification of the source of the infection and show the patterns of transmission.
The objective of this study was to determine the prevalence of infection with T. gondii among three indigenous populations in Brazil with different degrees of acculturation (isolated, intermittent contact, and continuous contact with other groups) and the presence of different environmental risk factors. Seroprevalence was determined with respect to tribal ethnicity, geographic region, and sex.
| POULATIONS AND METHODS |
|
|
|---|
|
Constant contact population: Tiriyó.
The Tiriyó inhabit the frontier area along the border between northern Brazil and Suriname. They are composed of a population of 1,700 individuals, of whom which 750 live in Brazil, and inhabit an area in the northwestern part of the Tumucumaque Park. The region is characterized geographically by the plains, fields, forests and mountains in northern Pará (Figure 1
). Beginning in 1960, they began to settle with missionaries. They are currently distributed in Brazil among 12 villages close to the base of the Franciscan Mission known as "Mission Tiriós."10 The "Mission Tiriós" has an infrastructure with several improvements, such as chlorinated water and electricity, and resembles any small city in interior Brazil.
Ethical guidelines. Research projects dealing with the health of the indigenous Indian tribes in the eastern, central, and northern Brazil are authorized after vigorous examination by several authorities in Brazil. The Operação Amazôia Nativa (Native Amazonia Operation) reviewed and approved the current project. In addition, this project was reviewed and approved by the ethical commission of the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (Project 25000.098034/2001-46) and the National Commission on Ethics in Research. Informed consent was obtained from all the members of the Indian tribes and their children through help from the Brazilian National Agency for Indian Affairs/Brazilian National Health Foundation of the Ministry of Health. This study is an integral part of the project of "Health of the Indigenous People of Brazil."
Serologic study. All blood samples were collected by vein puncture. Blood samples were collected from 148 individuals in the Enawenê-Nawê tribe. This sample represented 60.4% of the total population (n = 245) and included men, women, and children 675 years of age. Similarly, 302 blood samples were collected from individuals 469 years old of both sexes in the Waiãpi tribe. This represented 67.1% of the total population (n = 450). Five hundred sixty-eight blood samples were collected from individuals 490 years old of both sexes in the Tiriyó tribe. This represented 75.7% of the total population (n = 750).
Laboratory methods. Analysis of serum samples from 1,018 individuals of the three indigenous tribes was carried out at the FIOCRUZ Toxoplasmosis Laboratory in Rio de Janeiro. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was used for detection of IgG antibodies to T. gondii.12 The cut-off point for the IgG-ELISA was established by assaying 12 negative standard serum samples and four positive serum samples on four different plates. The cut-off for each plate consisted of the mean reading of the negative serum sample plus two standard deviations. A correction factor was determined by dividing the median of the cut-off value by the average reading of the negative sera in these plates.
An indirect immunofluorescence antibody (IFA) assay was used for the detection of IgM antibodies and specific IgG antibodies. Four different dilutions of serum ranging from 1:16 to 1:4,096 were made in phosphate-buffered saline. For detection, conjugated anti-IgM and anti-IgG human fluorescent antibodies diluted 1:50 were used. This dilution was established after analysis with standard reactive and non-reactive serum. A reaction with a serum dilution
1:16 was considered reactive, and the final titer was the last dilution that still showed fluorescence in the periphery of the parasites. The fluorescent tests were performed according to the method of Camargo.13 The material was examined using an epi-fluorescence microscope (Y-FL; Nikon, Tokyo, Japan) using a 40x objective, a 10x ocular lens, an ND16 exciting filter, and a mercury lamp.
The IFA assay was standardized in our laboratory and showed comparable sensitivity and specificity as that of the Sabin Feldman dye test, which is regarded as the gold standard. The titers measured by the IFA assay and the dye test are comparable.13,14 All serum samples in the IgM-IFA assay were tested for the presence of the rheumatoid antibodies using a diagnostic kit (Bio Lab Mérieux SA, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil).15 Serum reactive for T. gondii were retested with an immunoenzymatic assay for IgM antibodies (Platelia® Toxoplasma gondii IgM tetramethilbenzidine; Bio-Rad Laboratories, Marnes la Coquette, France).
Statistical analysis.
Chi-square tests were used to compare the prevalence of seropositivity in relation to the sex and age. A P value
0.05 was considered significant.16 A non-parametric test of trend in ordered groups was also used.17 The prevalence of infection among the indigenous populations was standardized by the adjusting direct method.18 Finally, to locate heterogeneity in the distributions of the antibody titers, partition of chi-square was performed.16 The Kappa statistic was determined and comparison between the two diagnostic tests against the same gold standard in the same sample (IFA assay as the gold standard) was performed.19,20
| RESULTS |
|
|
|---|
The samples was stratified and analyzed by sex to evaluate its effect on the distribution of infection with T. gondii. In the Enawenê-Nawê, 86.1% of the males and 75.9% of the females were positive for IgG antibodies (
2 = 2.43, P = 0.119). In the Waiãpi 59.2% of the males and 60.0% of the females were positive (
2 = 0.0183, P = 0.892). In the Tiriyó, 59.2% of the males and 52.1% of the females were positive (
2 = 2.92, P = 0.088).
Significant heterogeneity was observed among the age groups in the three tribes studied. A non-parametric test showed a significant trend of antibody positivity increasing with age (Table 1
).
|
|
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
|
|---|
The high prevalence of antibodies to T. gondii in the Enawenê-Nawê cannot be easily explained by the more common forms of transmission of toxoplasmosis, such as the ingestion of cysts present in raw meat or inadequately cooked meat and the presence of oocysts in the feces of cats. This is because the Enawenê-Nawê eat fish, but do not consume any red meat and do not have cats as pets. Furthermore, the low density of wild felines dispersed over large areas does not result in the high levels of soil contamination that explain the high levels of antibodies to T. gondii in the Enawenê-Nawê. A possible source could be the concentration of wild felines at water collection sites used by these Indians. At theses sites, as in other areas of Brazil, unfiltered water has been considered a risk factor for infection with T. gondii.23 The living habits of the Enawenê-Nawê and Waiãpi are similar in relation to their contacts with the soil and the consumption of larva and insects. Therefore, this can expose them to the oocysts of T. gondii. It was expected that the prevalence of the infection among these two tribes would be similar and different from that of the Tiriyó, whose living habits are closer to those of the non-Indians. However, the seroprevalence of T. gondii among the Waiãpi and the Tiriyó were very similar, 59.6% and 55.6% respectively, and different from that of the Enawenê-Nawê.
Some investigators attribute great importance to the consumption of red meat and its relationship to the high seropositivity of antibodies to T. gondii.6 This fact is supported by a study performed with the Ticuna Indians, in whom antibody titers
1:256 were higher in some villages, where the alimentary habits were more varied, and similar to populations of non-Indians, than in the villages whose source of animal protein was predominantly fish.6 However in our study of the Enawenê-Nawê, who do not consume any red meat, the frequency of antibody titers
1:256 in 27.7% was higher than among the populations of Tiriyó (9.08%) and Waiãpi (8.56%), whose diets include this type of food.
No significant differences with respect to infection with T. gondii were detected between males and the females in the three tribes studied. These findings are similar to those described in the Indians of High Xingu, among whom 46.9% of the men and 56.5% of the women tested positive for antibodies to T. gondii.4 A similar study in the Amapá showed that 71.2% the males and 66.5% of the females were positive for antibodies to T. gondii.24 These results suggest that the rate of infection for T. gondii is not sex related, or that the differences observed are not important, bearing in mind the fact that activities performed by men and women among these three tribes are quite different and that most of them had varying degrees of frequent contact with risk factors.
The high frequency of low IFA assay titers of 1:16 and 1:64 to T. gondii observed among the three indigenous tribes studied (Table 3
) are similar to those detected among the of natives of High Xingu (51.1%), in whom IFA assay titers varied from 1:16 to 1:256.4 Among the populations studied, only four males had titers of 1:4,096: one in the Enawenê-Nawê, two in the Waiãpi, and one in the Tiriyó. None of the Enawenê-Nawê showed reactivity for IgM. Five of the Waiãpi and one of the Tiriyó were reactive for IgM. With a smaller number of IgM-reactive individuals and a larger number of IgG-reactive individuals among these tribes, there may be chronic infection with T. gondii among these three tribes. This was also suggested by Coimbra and Santos,25 who indicated that toxoplasmosis was an endemic zoonosis."
With regard to the age groups seropositivity in the Enawenê-Nawê begins to plateau starting from the third decade of life. However, this occurs later in the other two tribes. As in other studies,26,27 we found that the frequency of infection with T. gondii increases with age. This is because with age, the probability that an individual may make contact with at least one of the transmission mechanisms also increases.28,29
The high frequency of infection with T. gondii in younger age groups suggests that these children have already been exposed to risk factors for acquiring the infection because 50% of the children less than 10 years old were seropositive by the ELISA or IFA assay and four of them had IgG-IFA assay antibodies titers > 1:64.
The harmful effects of the acculturation process in the health of the Amerindians are well documented in relation to the presence of many infections such as hepatitis, tuberculosis, and other viral diseases. In a study of the Amerindians of Venezuela, it was observed that the acculturation process elevated the prevalence of toxoplasmosis because those individuals had started to have a more sedentary lifestyle, including the presence of domestic cats in households and the use of a community water supply.30
However, in group studies, the degree of contact with non-Indians does not seems to be responsible for an increase in the seropositivity, which seems to be more related to the life and cultural habits of each of the Indian populations. The Tiriyó showed an infection rate for T. gondii of 43% in 1974 (150 analyzed by the dye test) when they were considered an isolated polulation.31 Currently, the Tiriyó have much greater contact with the non-Indians, a higher degree of acculturation, and the infection rate for T. gondii has increased to 55.6% (568 tested). This is a significant increase when compared with the previous rate (
2 = 7.50, P = 0.006). In the Tiriyó, contact with non-Indians did not influence the activities of the group that could expose them to risk factors for infection with T. gondii. In the present study, the Enawenê-Nawê, who had fewer contacts with non-Indians, showed the highest seroprevalence for toxoplasmosis.
When we analyzed the three indigenous populations and adjusted for confounding effects caused by sex and age, for the direct method of standardization of the coefficients (Table 2
), it was observed that the rates of seropositivity in the Waiãpi and of the Tiriyó were similar. Furthermore, it was observed that the seropositivity and the distribution of the IFA assay titers in the Enawenê-Nawê were different from those of the other tribes. Therefore, it is suggested that the Enawenê-Nawê are in contact with some other risk factor(s) that lead to an increase in the prevalence of antibodies to T. gondii, and that these factors are not as common in the other two tribes studied.
The Enawenê-Nawê have different dietary habits compared with the Waiãpi and the Tiriyó, mainly with respect to the consumption of mushrooms located in the forests with large amounts of organic matter in the soil. In addition, the living area of the Enawenê-Nawê may be visited by wild felines in search of water and could become contaminated with oocysts eliminated in their feces. Thus, exposure to this environment may result in the difference in seropositivity for T. gondii in the Enawenê-Nawê in comparison to the other two tribes studied.
Received August 26, 2003. Accepted for publication February 5, 2004.
Acknowledgments: We thank Operação Amazônia Nativa (OPAN) for providing ethnologic data for the Indian tribes, Regiane Trigueiro Vicente for technical laboratory assistance, the Director of the Protozoology Laboratory of the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation for permission to use their laboratories, and Dr. Ronald Blanton (Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH) for editing the manuscript.
Financial support: This work was supported by CNPq Project 131462/00-8 from the Brazilian National Agency for Research.
Authors addresses: Cleide A. Sobral and Maria Regina R. Amendoeira, Department of Protozoology, Av. Brasil 4365, Pavilhão Arthur Neiva, Sala 1B, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, CEP 21 045 900. Antonio Teva, Department of Immunology, Instituto Oswaldo Cruz da Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Av. Brasil 4365, Pavihão 26, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil CEP 21 045 900. Balmukund N. Patel, The State University of Feira de Santana, Caixa Postal 252-294, Feira de Santana CEP 44031-460, Bahia, Brazil. Carlos H. Klein, Department of Epidemiology, Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Av. Brasil 4365 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil CEP 21 045 900.
Reprint requests: Maria Regina R. Amendoeira, Department of Protozoology, Av. Brasil 4365, Pavilhão Arthur Neiva, Sala 1B, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, CEP 21 045 900, Telephone: 55-21-2598-4336 or 4337, Fax: 55-21-2280-5449 or 2598 4220. E-mails: amendoeira{at}fiocruz.br and mramendoeira{at}bridge.com.br.
| REFERENCES |
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |