|
|
||||||||
| ABSTRACT |
|
|
|---|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
|
|---|
As techniques become available to assess genotypic associations at the population level, considerable variation has been noted in natural populations of schistosomes.1,2 Recent work in Zimbabwe demonstrated that schistosomes derived from snails along non-connected river systems showed substantial genetic diversity, with genetic distance increasing with geographic separation.3 Brouwer and others4 have shown that schistosomes found among Zimbabwean school children living in the same general area can be clustered into a series of related groups that share similar genotypes.
Few data exist on the genetic variability of the parasite Schistosoma haematobium in human populations and the potential existence of associated pathology. Therefore, the present study was undertaken to assess both genetic variability of the parasite and the level of pathology in students from a hyperendemic area of Zimbabwe by using ultrasound examination of urinary tract organs. Parasite samples were taken from a subset of students to determine the level of parasite genetic diversity in the area. Genetic markers were then compared with clinical outcome. By examining these issues, we endeavored to identify and characterize S. haematobium diversity within its definitive host and explore its possible implication on disease outcome.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|
|
|---|
Population. The population studied was composed of children 916 years of age from three primary schools. Criteria for inclusion of individuals in the study were 1) informed consent for ultrasound examination and consent to provide a series of fecal and urine specimens, 2) a minimum age of nine years, and 3) no obvious indicator of ill health or other confounding aspect of health status. Between June 1998 and May 1999, 551 children participated in the survey.
Patient identifiers on all information were coded so as to maintain privacy. All infected participants were given a single dose of 40 mg/kg of praziquantel (Biltricide®; Bayer, Ltd., Leverkussen, Germany) at the conclusion of the investigation at their school. Informed consent was obtained from adult participants and parents or legal guardians of minors involved in the study. The study was approved by the Medical Research Council of Zimbabwe and the Institutional Review Board of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
Parasitologic measures. From each participant, fecal specimens were screened for S. mansoni and geohelminths.8 Additionally, a total of three urine specimens per student were collected on alternating days to survey the prevalence of S. haematobium.9 Collections were made between 10:00 AM and 2:00 PM to ensure maximum yield.10 Measurements were expressed as the arithmetic mean number of eggs passed per 10 mL of urine. To determine the presence and extent of hematuria and proteinuria, dipsticks (Hemastix®; Bayer Diagnostics, Fernwald, Germany) were also used on all urine specimens.
Ultrasound examinations. To avoid confounding with the S. haematobium pathologic assessment, students with S. mansoni- or geohelminth-positive stool specimens (n = 73) and those from whom we did not receive a fecal specimen (n = 22) were excluded from the pathologic assessment. Of the remaining 456 students, 256 were infected with S. haematobium. Since the purpose of the study was to look for epidemiologic or genetic differences among those infected with urinary schistosomiasis, only 17% (33 of 190) of those uninfected were given ultrasound examinations compared with 71% (189 of 266) of those students infected with S. haematobium. The S. haematobium-infected students who did not undergo ultrasound examination, either because they did not show up on the assessment days or were lacking other parasitologic data, did not differ significantly in intensity of infection or major demographic characteristics from those who were given ultrasound examinations and those who had dual S. mansoni and S. haematobium infections.
Ultimately, ultrasonographic assessments were performed on 222 of the children with a portable ultrasound device (UF-5800A; Fukuda Denshi Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) with a 3.5 MHz standard size convex probe. Bladders were examined when full and the ultrasonographer was unaware of patient infection status. A transverse measurement of the bladder was taken and pathology was classified according to thickening, presence of polyps, or the existence of masses protruding into the lumen. Such pathology was divided into the following categories based on World Health Organization:11 0 = no pathology: wall <5 mm; no masses, polyps, or thickenings (Figure 1A
); 1 = mild: wall <5 mm; focal thickenings, no masses or polyps; 2 = severe: wall
5 mm; and/or masses or polyps (Figure 1B
).
|
2 cm parenchyma or end-stage with absence of parenchyma (Figure 1DQuestionnaire. Participants were questioned in regards to type and duration of water contact activities. A sense of the length of the current infection was determined by past or present occurrence of perceived symptoms as well as treatment history. Travel, age, weight, sex, and education information were also collected. All data were transferred from the collection sheets into Epi-Info 6.04b (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA). Additionally, a worker from the Ministry of Health who had lived in the area interviewed students in regards to the approximate position of their residence and type and location of each water contact activity.
Parasite genetics. Based on damage to the kidney or bladder, adequate urinary egg counts (for infecting laboratory-bred snails), and access to complete parasitologic information, 13 students with severe pathology and 12 with mild pathology were randomly selected from the two pathology groups for genetic characterization of their infections. Mild pathology was defined as bladder and kidney pathology each of grades 1 or less. A person was considered to have severe pathology if they had the highest grade of bladder pathology and/or the highest grade of kidney pathology. Two or three additional urine specimens were taken from each student for monomiracidial exposures of 4896 snails per student.2,4 Snails were maintained through patency and cercariae were collected periodically. In all, 133 parasite isolates were obtained by this method. A polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was done with four random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) primers on all cercarial material from patent infections.2,4 For each monomiracidial isolate, the presence or absence of bands at 53 different loci were entered into a Microsoft (Bellevue, WA) Excel® database.2
Analytical methods. Genetic analyses were done as detailed by Shiff and others2 and Brouwer and others.4 Allele frequencies at each locus and overall heterozygosity were compared between isolates from severely and mildly infected patients using RAPDBIOS followed by BIOSYS-2.12,13 An analysis of molecular variance was calculated to find the contribution of each population to the total genetic variance.14 This is essentially an analysis of variance based on the genotype banding patterns produced by RAPD-PCR and is used to compare intra-population and inter-population variances.
We have introduced an additional procedure that is helpful in providing a picture of the genetic relationships among individuals within panmictic populations. It is based on a cluster analysis derived from matched pairs of alleles detected by RAPD-PCR. It does not represent permanent associations between related individuals, but gives an estimate of related groupings of the population at a particular time. As such, it is useful to examine the interrelationships of individual parasites and their hosts. We have termed these relationships clusters of associated genotypes.4 Genotypic clusters of the parasites were determined by analysis of loci with prevalence higher than 0.1 and less than 0.6, assuming Hardy-Weinberg proportions in the overall population. These values were chosen based on a previous study showing that loci with these frequencies optimally estimate the number of genetically related families in a panmictic population.15 In our field population, we do not know the parentage of isolates yet the groupings, whether representing true sibling families or simply closely related groups of schistosomes, are useful in comparing parasite genetics. Differences in the number and type of parasite clusters represented by the populations of parasites derived from mild and severe patients were compared. Essentially Apostol and others15 showed with the mosquito Aedes aegypti that it was feasible to use DNA fingerprinting (RAPD-PCR) to estimate the number of full sibling families in individuals arising from oviposition sites. The similarity of pairs of individuals are measured by examining the shared absence and presence of bands to estimate the fraction of matches (M) using the formula M = NAB/NT, where NAB is the total number of matches in individuals A and B (i.e., both bands absent or present) and NT is the total number of loci scored in the overall study. An M value of 1 indicates that two individuals have identical patterns and a value of 0 means they are completely different.
Values of M are calculated among all n(n - 1)/2 pairs of n individuals to develop an estimate of a value for 1 - M that will separate clusters of full siblings.15 The discriminating value averaging over all loci from the entire population is calculated using the program MCALC.13 This then is applied using those polymorphic loci to estimate the number of families (or clusters of associated genotypes when true parentage cannot be confirmed) represented by groups of related genotypes using the program FINGERS.13
Questionnaire and summarized genetic data were further analyzed in SPSS 10.0 for Windows (SPSS, Inc., Chicago IL). An odds ratio (OR), Pearson chi-square, or chi-square for trend was used, where appropriate, to measure associations among ordinal data. An analysis of variance was performed when the response variable was numeric. Correlation of variables was determined before fitting a multivariate logistic regression model using variables found significant in the univariate analysis. P values
0.05 using a two-sided test were considered significant.
| RESULTS |
|
|
|---|
Genetic frequencies.
Cercarial material derived from 73 miracidial isolates from those with severe infections were compared with 60 from those with little to no urinary system damage. Four RAPD primers produced 53 unambiguous loci, of which 22 (41.5%) were polymorphic. Details of banding patterns of these primers, including gel electrophoretic patterns, have been published elsewhere.2,4 When looking at the presence or absence of dominant bands, distributions at eight of the polymorphic loci differed appreciably between those derived from patients with severe or mild infections (
2 = 35.4, P < 0.01) (Table 1
). Allelic frequencies, after taking into account the effect of dominance and Hardy Weinberg proportions,12,13 yielded similar relationships.
|
|
|
Clusters and pathology.
The arithmetic mean parasite egg count was 217 eggs/10 mL of urine (median = 140) for those with severe urinary tract pathology compared with 76 eggs/10 mL of urine (median = 62) for those with mild pathology (F = 5.15, P = 0.03). Persons with higher egg counts tended to have more parasite clusters represented in their infection (
2 for trend = 3.10, P = 0.08 (Figure 2
). Those with more diverse infections (clusters/number of isolates) were also more likely to have proteinuria (mean ± SD clusters/total isolates = 0.76 ± 0.23) compared with those without proteinuria (0.41 ± 0.17; F = 9.32, P < 0.01). However, there was no significant difference in number of parasite clusters per infection for severe versus mild pathology as assessed by ultrasound.
|
in Table 1
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
|
|---|
With new methods to evaluate the clinical outcome of schistosomiasis in humans, such as portable ultrasound machines, and ever improving techniques for molecular characterization of the parasite, we embarked upon a study of S. haematobium genetic diversity in humans. The current study, although limited in size, indicates that the extent of S. haematobium diversity in humans reflects that seen in the intermediate snail host and that there are significant associations between certain genetic clusters of the parasite and clinical outcome.
While a number of animal models have been developed to explore pathology caused by S. mansoni and S. japonicum,2325 developing an animal model for S. haematobium has been complicated by the fact that it is primarily an anthroponosis. The laboratory animal models created thus far have failed to duplicate the type of bladder wall pathology and kidney pathology (due to obstruction of the ureters rather than immune complexes) seen in humans.2628 We were able to avoid this issue by exploring genetic diversity of S. haematobium, and its possible relationship to pathology, directly in school children from a single communal land in Zimbabwe. Although limited by the fact that we cannot control host factors, such as differences in exposure and host genetics, we have attempted to minimize such confounding by controlling for variables from our questionnaire that were related to pathology. From miracidia obtained from 25 students, 133 distinct parasite isolates were amplified in snails and subsequently characterized by RAPD-PCR. Banding patterns at 53 loci showed moderate diversity of the local parasite population, with a mean heterozygosity of 0.116. This figure is similar to that seen with different RAPD primers in a survey of schistosome genotypes in Bulinids.1
For Plasmodium falciparum, it has been suggested that clinical malaria is possibly related to the human immunologic response when encountering new strains of the parasite.29,30 Similarly, with the immune response to parasite eggs responsible for most schistosomiasis-related pathology, increased diversity of schistosome genotypes could lead to repeated activation of the immune system with more or larger granulomas developing. When we assessed whether diversity of S. haematobium infection was greater for those with as compared with those without severe pathology, our findings showed no relationship between either heterozygosity or number of parasite clusters per infection and urinary tract pathology (Tables 2
and 3
). There was, however, a trend of increasing diversity as the intensity of infection (as estimated by urinary egg counts) increased (Figure 2
). This may be related to the behaviors that led to development of such intense infection in the first place. If intensely infected students participated in repeated and extended water contact activities, the chance for exposure to a number of parasite genotypes would likely increase. This was in accordance with the observation that males, who had more water contact and more intense infections than females, also tended to have greater numbers of parasite clusters per number of isolates obtained. Those with more diverse infections (clusters/number of isolates) were also more likely to have proteinuria.
Virulence of particular parasite strains, rather than diversity of an infection, is another possible contributor to disease development. Genetic differences may lead to some strains being innately more immunogenic or fecund than others. In exploring this hypothesis, it was found that at a number of loci there were significant differences in frequencies of dominant bands between samples derived from mildly or severely infected persons (Table 1
). Upon dividing the population into clusters of associated genotypes using a technique developed by Apostol and others,15 it was found that three clusters occurred almost exclusively in severe infections and one was over-represented in those with mild infections (Tables 3
and 4
). Inspection of allelic distributions for each of these four clusters revealed that cluster 1 (severe) and cluster 7 (mainly mild) had inverse genotypes at loci significantly different between pathologic groups (Table 1
, loci marked by an
). These findings support the notion that particular parasite strains or genetic factors may be associated with clinical outcome. The actual reasons behind these pathologic differences may be many. Antigenic differences may lead to more or less intense immune reactions to the infection. Another possibility is that certain parasite strains may be more fecund than others. Mean egg counts for those harboring clusters over-represented in severe infections were considerably higher (although not significantly so) than the mean egg count for cluster 7, which was over-represented in mild infections (Table 4
). Increased fecundity of parasites in these clusters could be the reason behind the increased pathology in hosts harboring them.
The possible implications of these genetic differences between isolates derived from mild or severe infections warrant further investigation. Laboratory studies have shown that S. haematobium infections may differ under controlled circumstances, where factors such as exposure to parasites, infection intensity, nutrition, and host genetics are kept as similar as possible. Comparisons between Nigerian and Iranian strains showed differential mortality and worm recovery in hamsters. They also differed in degree of snail infectivity.31 More recently Thiongo and others32 investigated S. mansoni strains from two districts in Kenya known for their disparate rates of hepatomegaly and splenomegaly despite comparable fecal egg output.33 When the two strains were passaged through mice, significant differences were found in the egg excretion/ egg retention ratio for mice (P < 0.001), with the strain that had less retention corresponding to the area with less human pathology. Although our study in human subjects did not allow for strict control of host factors, as can be done in animal studies, we were able to control statistically for a number of other variables associated with pathology (Table 6
). In our multivariate model, parasite genetics remained a significant contributor to clinical outcome (OR = 3.95, P = 0.021) (Table 6
).
To our knowledge the present investigation is the first study to look at genetic diversity of S. haematobium within schoolchildren. It is also the first to compare the distribution of S. haematobium genotypes in the definitive host with clinical outcome. While limited in size and scope, the study provides evidence of parasite factors significantly associated with disease outcome. Further characterization of the parasite clusters associated with severe clinical outcome and comparison to the one cluster with over-representation in mild infections may reveal a possible genetic mechanism for parasite virulence. Since one cannot rule out the possibility that pathology develops over time and that the parasites that make up the current infection are not necessarily responsible for all pathology seen, an expanded, longitudinal study would be required to confirm associations between particular parasite clusters and morbidity. Given the disparity in clinical outcomes and the possible importance of genetic variability when considering drug or vaccine targets, clearly there is great need to learn more about the genetics of this parasite.
Received March 8, 2002. Accepted for publication December 9, 2002.
Acknowledgments: We thank the field staff of the Blair Research Laboratory who facilitated collection and processing of parasitologic samples. We are very grateful to the Chikwaka District Health Office, the staff of the Bosha Rural Health Centre, and the Nyagui, Chipangura, and Mavhudzi schools for their cooperation with our surveys. Thanks are due to the Japan International Cooperation Agency, which provided us with the ultrasound machine for examinations. Special thanks are given to Dr. Fred Lewis, Dr. Yung-San Liang, and Francis Barnes (Biomedical Research Institute, Rockville, MD) for providing snails and parasite material for the study.
Financial support: This work received financial support from the National Institutes of Health (grant 1 RO3 DK53207-01 and training grant T32 AI-07417) and the J. William Fulbright Fellowship program.
Authors addresses: Kimberly C. Brouwer and Clive J. Shiff, The W. Harry Feinstone Department of Molecular Microbiology & Immunology, Bloomberg School of Public Health, 615 N. Wolfe Street, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21205, Telephone: 410-955-1263, Fax: 410-955-0105, E-mail: cshiff{at}jhsph.edu. Patricia D. Ndhlovu and Anderson Munatsi, Blair Research Laboratory, Ministry of Health and Child Welfare, Harare, Zimbabwe. Yukiko Wagatsuma, Department of International Health, Bloomberg School Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21205.
| REFERENCES |
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. M. Neal Schistosomiasis - An Unusual Cause of Ureteral Obstruction: A Case History and Perspective Clin. Med. Res., November 1, 2004; 2(4): 216 - 227. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |