|
|
||||||||
| ABSTRACT |
|
|
|---|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
|
|---|
However, clinical consequences of Plasmodium falciparum chloroquine resistance also have been recognized: persistent parasitemia, return of clinical symptoms such as fever, and persistent anemia despite drug treatment.2,3 In addition, a study among children hospitalized with malaria in a district hospital in western Kenya showed a 3-fold higher risk of dying among those treated with chloroquine compared with patients treated with drugs to which P. falciparum was fully susceptible.4 Children who received chloroquine treatment had a 33% case-fatality rate within 8 weeks of hospitalization compared with an 11% rate among those who received either pyrimethamine/sulfa, quinine, or 5 days of trimethoprim/ sulfamethoxazole. Because of its striking effect on survival, pyrimethamine/sulfa has been provided since February 1992 as first-line therapy for children with malaria admitted to that hospital. The objective of this investigation was to evaluate the effect of changing drug treatment policy on the case-fatality rates of children hospitalized with malaria over a 4-year period.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|
|
|---|
Children received routine in-hospital evaluation and care by the SDH staff. The admission diagnosis assigned by the hospital staff and all treatments administered during hospitalization were recorded. Treatment decisions were made by the SDH medical staff assigned to care for pediatric patients. During the study period, chloroquine was the first-line drug for the treatment of malaria, according to Kenyan national policy. The treatment that each patient received for malaria was recorded for a systematically sampled subgroup of children who were enrolled in concurrent studies.
This study was approved by the scientific steering and ethical review committees of the Kenya Medical Research Institute and the investigational review board of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Laboratory. Hemoglobin was measured from a capillary finger-prick using a HemocueR* (Mission Viejo, CA) machine. Thick and thin blood smears were stained with 3% Giemsa for 30 minutes. The number and species of Plasmodium parasites were read per 300 white blood cells (WBC). Parasite density was calculated based on the number of WBC/ mm3 determined by the complete blood count. If the WBC count was not available, parasite density was calculated using the population mean of 8,000 WBC/mm3.
Analysis.
Data were analyzed using EpiInfo 5 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta) and SAS (SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, NC) statistical package software. Categorical variables were analyzed using frequency distributions, and differences among groups were assessed using
2 or Fishers exact tests, as appropriate. The Wilcoxon rank sum test or a two-tailed t test was used to compare the distribution of continuous variables. Direct standardization was used to account for differing distributions of malaria and severe anemia (defined as an admission capillary hemoglobin < 5.0 g/dL) among children admitted each year.5 The 1991 admission data were used as the standard population. The adjusted number of deaths each year among children with malaria was calculated separately for children with hemoglobin < or
5.0 g/dL, using the observed category-specific case-fatality rates for that year.
Malaria case definition.
Because of the high prevalence of falciparum parasitemia in this setting, (approximately 8090% of children in the community and over 60% of hospitalized children have a blood smear positive for asexual parasites of P. falciparum), the analysis was restricted to those children who met criteria for malaria illness.4 The case definition for malaria illness used was: a parasite density of
5,000 parasites/mm3 and documented axillary temperature of
37.5°C or a parasite density of
20,000 parasites/mm3 irrespective of documented temperature.
| RESULTS |
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
|
|---|
In this setting, the need to change drug treatment policy is apparent, but the real challenge is to recognize when first-line therapy is no longer effective before resistance is associated with significant malaria-related mortality. The controversy has been over identifying indicators to adequately monitor the consequences of resistance, including both parasitologic and clinical failures. Commonly used measurements to define responses to treatment have included parasitologic clearance at 72 hours, clinical status (recurrent fever) at 14 days, and hematologic recovery.7
At present, recommended standardized procedures in children younger than 5 include treatment at day 0, with follow-up parasite density and temperature measurements at days 3, 7, and 14.8,9 This approach targets the non-immune population at greatest risk for severe disease and provides information on the proportion of children who fail to eliminate their parasites and those who become ill again within a timeframe consistent with recrudescent infection rather than reinfection. Several sources have suggested that in vivo clinical failure rates of 1425% for a first-line treatment should indicate the need to change drug policy.8,10,11
Factors in the decision on when to change the first-line treatment will include programmatic considerations, assessment of costs, available second-line agents, and the acceptable proportion of clinical failures.12 The reluctance to abandon chloroquine is based, in part, on its low cost, wide availability, and acceptance. Chloroquine results in rapid initial improvement of clinical symptoms (e.g., headache and fever), which has contributed to its widespread acceptance and the perception that it remains effective, leading to an unwillingness of both health workers and patients to discontinue using chloroquine.
The higher cost of second-line treatment, such as FansidarR (pyrimethamine/sulfadoxine) or combination therapy with artemisinin derivatives, often is cited as prohibitive for most sub-Saharan countries where the average health-care expenditure per person is low. However, providing efficacious first-line treatment is more cost-effective when compared with the cost of recurrent illness and retreatment where drug resistance levels are high.8,10,11 The higher cost of second-line drugs and combination treatment protocols, as well as concern about the development of drug resistance in the "next"-line drug, although valid considerations, cannot justify withholding life-saving treatment.13 Of additional concern are observations suggesting that the use of chloroquine to treat chloroquine-resistant P. falciparum infections may lead to greater spread of the resistant strains because of enhanced gametocyte infectivitythus worsening the problem.14 The ongoing monitoring of drug resistance also will be important to detect the development of resistance in the "next-line" drug used or to detect regained sensitivity to a drug that has not been used recently, as has been described for chloroquine, to develop rational drug treatment policies.15
These observations in western Kenya were made in the context of routine care; except for providing anti-malarial medications, there were no changes in the care or availability of supportive therapies during the study period. In this setting, the most prevalent manifestation of severe P. falciparum illness is severe anemia. Overall, case-fatality rates were higher for severely anemic children than those whose hemoglobin levels were greater than 5.0 g/dL, but the benefits of effective malaria therapy did not depend on hemoglobin level and also were demonstrated for survival at 8 weeks after hospitalization, suggesting a causal role for recrudescent parasitemia.4 The malaria case-fatality rates among children hospitalized at SDH were reduced to approximately the 34% levels seen in developed countries and locations where cerebral malaria is more common.16,17 It is striking that in a different setting on the coast of Kenya, where 28% of children met the WHO criteria for cerebral malaria, the overall malaria case-fatality rate was 3.5%.17,18 These observations suggest that a case-fatality rate of 34% for malaria among hospitalized children, regardless of the case-mix of severe disease, may represent a useful measurement for monitoring overall quality of treatment.19 This observation will require validation from a number of sites to determine its utility.
This study was conducted in a health facility where laboratory testing was available, documentation of the treatment received was possible, and cause-specific mortality was obtained. The applicability of hospital-based observations to mortality patterns in the community may be questioned, as it is well recognized that most malaria-related deaths among children occur outside a health facility.20 However, recent evidence from Senegal supports the belief that increasing chloroquine resistance is also causing increased malaria-related child mortality at the community level.21 The need to ensure access to and availability of effective malaria treatment will be critical if we are to reduce the death toll caused by this disease.22
Improved child survival in Africa will require more-effective case management of malaria. Persistent parasitemia from treatment with an inefficacious drug is associated with increased malaria-related mortality. While we try to understand the clinical consequences of parasite resistance, we must not lose sight of the most important of all clinical outcomes: death. Efficacious therapy does improve survival, and this strategy is practical for implementation in hospital settings in Africa. Chloroquine resistance has been reported from all countries in sub-Saharan Africa; children are being treated with chloroquine in settings where clinical failures already exceed 25%.2328 The debate about chloroquine drug resistance is no longer about the increased cost of second-line medicationsit is about the cost of life. We cannot justify allowing children to die in Africa because they are not receiving effective treatment.
Received October 12, 2000. Accepted for publication May 2, 2002.
Acknowledgments: This paper is published with the permission of the Director, Kenya Medical Research Institute. We thank Johnson Awino, Solomon Twala, and Lucy Otieno for their participation in this study.
Financial support: This work was partly supported by the World Health Organization (Global Programme on AIDS, Division of Diarrheal and Acute Respiratory Disease Control, and the Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases).
Authors addresses: Jane R. Zucker, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Immunization Program, 2 Lafayette Street, 19th Floor, New York, NY 10007; Trenton K. Ruebush II, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Division of Parasitic Diseases, Mailstop F-22, 4770 Buford Highway, Atlanta, GA 34031; Charles Obonyo, Research Fellow, New England Medical Center, 750 Washington St., # 041, Boston, MA 02111; Juliana Otieno, Kisumu Provincial Hospital, PO Box 849, Kisumu, Kenya; Carlos C. Campbell, UNICEFHealth Section, 3 UN Plaza, New York, NY 10017.
Reprint requests: Dr. Jane R. Zucker, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Immunization Program, 2 Lafayette Street, 19th Floor, New York, NY 10007, Telephone: 212-676-2248, Fax: 212-676-2258, E-mail: jzucker{at}health.nyc.gov
* Use of trade names is for identification only and does not imply endorsement by the Public Health Service or the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ![]()
| REFERENCES |
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
Z. A Bhutta A major burden on children BMJ, April 26, 2008; 336(7650): 948 - 949. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J.A. Evans, J. May, D. Tominski, T. Eggelte, F. Marks, H.H. Abruquah, C.G. Meyer, C. Timmann, T. Agbenyega, and R.D. Horstmann Pre-treatment with chloroquine and parasite chloroquine resistance in Ghanaian children with severe malaria QJM, November 1, 2005; 98(11): 789 - 796. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. K. Baird Effectiveness of Antimalarial Drugs N. Engl. J. Med., April 14, 2005; 352(15): 1565 - 1577. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. Z. ABDEL-AZIZ, N. OSTER, A. STICH, B. COULIBALY, W. A. GUIGEMDE, H. WICKERT, K. T. ANDREWS, B. KOUYATE, and M. LANZER ASSOCIATION OF PLASMODIUM FALCIPARUM ISOLATES ENCODING THE P. FALCIPARUM CHLOROQUINE RESISTANCE TRANSPORTER GENE K76T POLYMORPHISM WITH ANEMIA AND SPLENOMEGALY, BUT NOT WITH MULTIPLE INFECTIONS Am J Trop Med Hyg, March 1, 2005; 72(3): 252 - 255. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. L. PITMANG, T. D. THACHER, J. K. A. MADAKI, D. Z. EGAH, and P. R. FISCHER COMPARISON OF SULFADOXINE-PYRIMETHAMINE WITH AND WITHOUT CHLOROQUINE FOR UNCOMPLICATED MALARIA IN NIGERIA Am J Trop Med Hyg, March 1, 2005; 72(3): 263 - 266. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |