The Relation of Beri-Beri to Polyneuritis from Other Causes
George C. Shattuck
From the Department of Tropical Medicine of the Harvard Medical School
1. It seems reasonable to suspect the existence of beri-beriwherever pellagra and scurvy are found, because all three diseasesdevelop on a basis of faulty nutrition and because beri-beriprobably may be combined with either pellagra or scurvy.
2.In the Far East a number of important factors are recognizedwhich may predispose or contribute to the development of beriberi.Among them are chronic malaria, pregnancy, climatic heat andmoisture, bad hygiene and various other debilitating conditions.
3. In the United States there are various forms of diseasewhichare debilitating and which may interfere seriously withnutritionas well. Polyneuritis, moreover, appears occasionallywith thesediseases. Among them may be mentioned chronic alcoholism,includingKorsakoff's syndrome, diabetes, cancer, tuberculosis,syphilis,pregnancy, and the marasmus of infants.
4. Someof the cases of polyneuritis developing with the abovementionedconditions might, perhaps, be properly regarded astrue beri-beriand not merely as complications or sequelae ofthe other diseases.But, because polyneuritis is not a commondisease in the UnitedStates, it is not likely that beri-beriis common here.
5.Inasmuch as there are no known criteria which are satisfactoryfor the diagnosis of beri-beri the therapeutic test should beapplied in doubtful cases. The usual course of polyneuritisis gradual, the convalescence requiring weeks or months. Onthe other hand, early cases of beri-beri respond quickly totreatment and this is particularly true of infants. Chroniccases of beriberi, in which extensive degeneration of nervesand muscles has taken place, cannot respond quickly to any formof treatment so that the therapeutic test would be of littlevalue in these cases.
6. Circulatory disorders with cardiachypertrophy and dilatationin a case of polyneuritis suggestthe diagnosis of beri-beribut may be due to other causes.
7.Conditions due to faulty nutrition are particularly commonininfants. Even breast-fed infants may suffer from them. Theberi-beriof infants in the Far East is said to develop, asa rule, inbreast-fed infants, and its occurrence is explainedby deficiencyin the diet of the nursing mother, even thoughshe may not herselfshow definite symptoms of beri-beri. A polyneuritisappearingin a nursing infant in this country might, perhaps,be due toberi-beri.